June 29, 2023
In a major win for nursing home residents and their families, the U.S. Supreme Court has upheld the right to sue government-run nursing homes under the Federal Nursing Home Reform Act (FNHRA). In a 7-2 decision, the court decided that these plaintiffs could seek relief in federal court.
Background of the Case
In 2019, the family of Gorgi Talevski, a patient with dementia who had been living at a state-owned nursing home in Indiana, sued the owner of the nursing home for violating Talevski’s rights.
They claimed that the facility’s alleged actions of overmedicating Talevski with psychotropic drugs and transferring him to a different facility without their permission were against the law. Talevski, a Medicaid recipient, died in 2021; his family asserted that his health had worsened as a result of the facility’s mistreatment.
The FNHRA prohibits using chemical restraint for discipline or convenience, and transfers are only permitted under limited circumstances. The federal court dismissed the case, stating that Talevski had no right to sue under FNHRA. However, the 7th Circuit reversed the decision, and the U.S. Supreme Court has now agreed that Talevski’s family can in fact sue the nursing home.
Upholding the Rights of Medicaid Recipients
The civil rights case, Health & Hospital Corp. of Marion County v. Talevski, became a closely watched legal battle across the nation. Under the Supreme Court’s ruling, individuals residing in publicly owned nursing facilities – and those who rely on government assistance programs such as Medicaid – can file federal lawsuits if they believe their rights have been violated.
In issuing its decision, the country’s highest court upheld its precedent in the Wilder v. Virginia Hospital Association case from 1990. That decision stated the Constitution’s Spending Clause authorizes federal lawsuits under Section 1983, which enforces the rights that are established by Congressional law.
What This Decision Means
While most government-run nursing homes are concentrated in Indiana, this decision will affect facilities that are owned by the state, county, or Veterans Administration.
Justice Elena Kagan said during oral arguments that while FNHRA is a big statute that says many things, “one of those things it does say to every nursing home facility [is that it] has to ensure that individual rights are respected and lays out in considerable detail what those rights are and says it’s [their] job to see that those rights are fulfilled.”
Advocates for older adults as well as people with disabilities, many of whom depend on public assistance programs, are lauding the ruling. In a news release issued by the American Civil Liberties Union, Susan Mizner, director of the organization’s Disability Rights Program, stated: “This decision is a crucial victory for the civil rights of nursing home residents, people with disabilities, and everyone protected under Titles VI and IX of the Civil Rights Act.”